Well, early results are starting to trickle in. Inventory is really really tight under $300k. Over $300k not so much, and over $400k it seems to be ok. Buyers are still going after anything under $300 that is livable, and new construction starts are off to an early start. Look for a lot of presales on units, thereby leaving the second tranche of builders to follow on, meaning, narrower margins, riskier deals, and eventually someone getting wiped out. I can see it happening again. Don’t we ever learn?
Buyers are going from trickle to flood, I expect pricing to firm up pretty quickly here, given these conditions. EVEN WITH the appraisal standards being so tight, and underwriting being mercurial at best, I’m going to go out on a limb and say we are going to see some price increases in the under $300,000 to 350,000 range. To date, inflation there (under $300) has been masked by the soft over $400 market, but that’s starting to go away. You’ll see some bumps (as we have all year, really, remember this time last year? The “cash flowing under $250,000” Month?) But they will be quick, and brief.
Our charts from the MLS tell a similar story. Inventory down, AVERAGE AND MEDIAN PRICE FLAT, but volume up, and statistically so. Average time on market remains static as well.
I recall a similar time in early 2000 when this same thing happened. Most people who earn near the average wage in this county had to buy under $300,000 and got, quite frankly, less for it – if they could even find anything at all.
Then things that sold over $400,000 were truly a function of inbounders, people moving to the area from other high cost areas so that a $400,000 house was a lateral, or even downward step.
Then things heated up, and many people started buying $400,000 second homes… ah yes, those were the days…
But no more. The $400+ range is becomming the domain of full time residents, and some specific, bankrolled second home owners, but not the flood of 2006-2007.
So the market is developing two lobes, under $300 Working in our community types, and Over $300 in a higher paying job (though few) or Inbounders, but even in both instances less than the number of buyers under $300 by a long shot.
Why does this matter? Because what sells in those ranges is important, because the Buyer’s makeup has shifted. There simply aren’t buyers of homes over $400,000 for second homes (or, there are, but very few) There used to be, but not much any more.
So as Sellers are updating the prices on their homes, they should also be thinking about WHO is going to buy that home. Up the valley over $400? It will be a tricky sell, because many of those second home buyers are now gone.
Not only do we need to update our prices, but we need to update our mental map about who is really coming out to buy those places, otherwise, it’s mark to fiction.
Until next time,
Maui